You see when I order key lime pie, I’d like the key lime pie to be the star of the show. Since that’s what I ordered.
Not some insanely stupid amount of meringue.
MTCarcus on
Seems like they skimped on the meringue /s
herroh7 on
i would be so mad if I ordered pie and I got this
hookums on
Holy moly that thing has a five-head. Did it taste good?
Seamore_J_Turtle on
If I ordered pie and it came with that much whipped cream I’d be happy, but that much merengue is a crime.
HeyThatLooksCool on
Key Lime is my favorite pie.
I would not order this lol.
Bomantheman on
Send it back
Hazywater on
I’d ask for a second plate for all the meringue I would not eat
tysnails on
That’s a lot of key and not a lot of lime
discordianofslack on
This is lime meringue pie.
NoCleverIDName on
Did you enjoy the side of Key Lime pie that came with the basketball-sized serving of meringue?
BanKenobi on
Blasphemy
Tcloud on
I think I’m the only one here that would enjoy the fuck outta that.
0dty0 on
That is a fine white chocolate baked alaska, sir. Now can you please show us the pie you said?
-no_aura- on
You guys are tripping. This looks awesome.
hakujo on
“Yes I would like a smidge of key lime pie with my meringue.”
Severe_Wind_4255 on
Key West memories
Clean_Mammoth_5646 on
Where’s the meringue?
Snarky75 on
That isn’t Key Lime Pie!!!!!
FaceMcShootie on
Reddit is such a weird place.
This looks insanely good
Seth_Gecko on
Now *that* is the right amount of meringue!
TheTaxman_cometh on
Who puts meringue on key line pie?
Pithecanthropus88 on
Classic case of “just because you can do a thing it doesn’t mean that you should.”
enderjaca on
spyker54 on
Y’know, maybe i’m old-fashioned. But i usually like more key-lime pie with my key-lime-pie
tingtangler on
Cockatoo pie
Djb0623 on
Id send this back
Notorious2again on
That’s a wild Guy Fieri. Put a pair of Oakleys on it and it has to do your bidding.
Xyrus2000 on
That’s not key lime pie. That’s a key lime sailboat.
Gonna have to tack that thing pretty hard to bring it to port.
antonboomboomjenkins on
nope
aleister94 on
LEGODamashii on
So here’s the thing, when you make Keylime pie, you use 5 egg yolks, which means you have 5 egg whites left over. That makes so much meringue, like easily a gallon in volume. I can definitely understand a restaurant making giant meringue Keylime pie their thing.
If that slice of Keylime pie had no meringue at all, it would still probably be worth it, since it is yellow and has what looks like homemade graham cracker crust (hard to see, but it’s there). And also assuming that they used actual Keylime juice (and not “Key West lime juice,” which seems to be some kind of citric potion that tastes similar to Keylime juice, but makes me irrationally angry, as a former South Floridian).
33 Comments
You see when I order key lime pie, I’d like the key lime pie to be the star of the show. Since that’s what I ordered.
Not some insanely stupid amount of meringue.
Seems like they skimped on the meringue /s
i would be so mad if I ordered pie and I got this
Holy moly that thing has a five-head. Did it taste good?
If I ordered pie and it came with that much whipped cream I’d be happy, but that much merengue is a crime.
Key Lime is my favorite pie.
I would not order this lol.
Send it back
I’d ask for a second plate for all the meringue I would not eat
That’s a lot of key and not a lot of lime
This is lime meringue pie.
Did you enjoy the side of Key Lime pie that came with the basketball-sized serving of meringue?
Blasphemy
I think I’m the only one here that would enjoy the fuck outta that.
That is a fine white chocolate baked alaska, sir. Now can you please show us the pie you said?
You guys are tripping. This looks awesome.
“Yes I would like a smidge of key lime pie with my meringue.”
Key West memories
Where’s the meringue?
That isn’t Key Lime Pie!!!!!
Reddit is such a weird place.
This looks insanely good
Now *that* is the right amount of meringue!
Who puts meringue on key line pie?
Classic case of “just because you can do a thing it doesn’t mean that you should.”
Y’know, maybe i’m old-fashioned. But i usually like more key-lime pie with my key-lime-pie
Cockatoo pie
Id send this back
That’s a wild Guy Fieri. Put a pair of Oakleys on it and it has to do your bidding.
That’s not key lime pie. That’s a key lime sailboat.
Gonna have to tack that thing pretty hard to bring it to port.
nope
So here’s the thing, when you make Keylime pie, you use 5 egg yolks, which means you have 5 egg whites left over. That makes so much meringue, like easily a gallon in volume. I can definitely understand a restaurant making giant meringue Keylime pie their thing.
If that slice of Keylime pie had no meringue at all, it would still probably be worth it, since it is yellow and has what looks like homemade graham cracker crust (hard to see, but it’s there). And also assuming that they used actual Keylime juice (and not “Key West lime juice,” which seems to be some kind of citric potion that tastes similar to Keylime juice, but makes me irrationally angry, as a former South Floridian).
Is that at the Fish House in Key Largo?